How probate costs work in New York
Probate in New York runs through the Surrogate's Court in the county where the person lived — New York (Manhattan), Kings (Brooklyn), Queens, Bronx, Richmond (Staten Island), Nassau, Suffolk, Westchester and the state's 62 counties. New York sets the executor commission by statute, leaves attorney fees to the court, and — for larger estates — adds a state estate tax with a notorious "cliff."
1. Executor commission — SCPA § 2307
The commission is on sums received and paid out, and excludes property specifically bequeathed in the will. The executor can waive it — and family members who are also beneficiaries often do, since it's taxable income.
2. Attorney fees — court-approved, no %
Under SCPA § 2110, attorney compensation is fixed by the Surrogate's Court as reasonable — there's no statutory percentage. In practice fees commonly run 3% to 5% of the estate, so a mid-sized New York estate can carry an attorney bill comparable to the executor commission.
3. Surrogate's Court filing fee — SCPA § 2402
4. The New York estate tax — and the cliff
This makes an estate just over the line pay a tax that can exceed the amount that pushed it over. Estates anywhere near $7–8 million need careful planning (lifetime gifts survived by 3 years, disclaimer trusts). New York has no inheritance tax.
5. When probate can be simplified in New York
- Voluntary administration (small estate) — for $50,000 or less in personal property, no real estate (SCPA § 1301).
- Living trust, joint tenancy, POD/TOD — pass assets outside probate, avoiding the commission and filing fee.
| Cost component | New York figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Executor commission | 5/4/3/2.5/2% scale | SCPA § 2307 |
| Attorney fee | Court-approved; ~3–5% (no statute) | SCPA § 2110 |
| Filing fee | $45–$1,250 by estate size | SCPA § 2402 |
| Small estate limit | $50,000 (personal property) | SCPA § 1301 |
| Estate tax | Exemption $7.35M; cliff at 105%; to 16% | NY Tax § 952 |
| Inheritance tax | None | NYS Tax |